Archive for category CNET

Panasonic DMP-BD30K Blu-ray Player Now $259

Panasonic DMP-BD30K Blu-ray player with Remote

The cost of Blu-ray players continues to fall before the 2008 Holidays. Buy.com has cut the price of the Panasonic DMP-BD30K from $399 to $259 with free shipping. The DMP-BD30K is a profile 1.1 player with 1080p/24fps output and 1080p DVD upconversion.

Price of the Panasonic DM-BP30

CNET rated the player a 6.6 out of 10. They loved the picture quality, but didn’t like the lack of in-player decoding for high-resolution audio and that it has no ethernet jack for firmware upgrades. See CNET’s video review below.

We still like the Sony BDP-S350, a Profile 2.0 player (with firmware update) that can be found for around $275 on Amazon, but the Panasonic is likely to see its price fall even lower in the near future.

Other Helpful Links:

Buy.com link.
CNET review.
Ultimate AV Magazine review.
High-Def Digest review.
Home Theater HiFi review.
AVS Forum thread for the Panasonic DMP-BD30.

CNET’s Review of the Vizio VO47L

Vizio VO47L Tilted Sideways

CNET’s HD guru David Katzmaier has published a thorough review of the Vizio VO47L, giving it a score of 6.2 out of 10. Positives for the television include a bargain price, good color reproduction, 4 HDMI inputs, good screen uniformity, good-looking all-black bezel and speakers, and a comfortable remote control. The cons are poor black levels, the need to adjust the color settings out of the box, and only two aspect ratios for viewing HD content.

“[The VO47L's] image quality stands solidly in the middle of the road, with those lighter black levels and subpar off-angle viewing characteristics seen on many other budget LCDs, but balanced by good color accuracy, at least after adjustment. You can still find numerous larger, 50-inch plasmas available for around the same price, but if you must have LCD and want a big screen for smaller money, the VO47LF deserves strong consideration.”

The score Katzmaier assigns the VO47L, 6.2, seems surprisingly low, as the Vizio GV47LF, 47-inch Vizio LCD the VO47L replaced (and is essentially the same as), is rated at 6.6. Perhaps the low score is an indication of the scales tipping in favor of plasma televisions, which, on average, offer a must better viewing experience than LCDs. Just browsing through CNET’s scores shows lower scores on average for most LCDs compared with plasmas. The main justification for the VO47L’s low score seems to be poor black levels, which have tended to be a strength for plasma technology.

Katzmaier’s mention of the VO47L’s better than average screen uniformity comes as a surprise, as Vizios (and most LCDs, in fact) are notorius for a clouding effect on dark screens. The VO47L’s good screen uniformity should come as a big plus for those thinking about buying the television, as it’s a rare attribute for bargain televisions. However, Katzmaier does mention noticing one corner of the screen is brighter than the rest. I’ve had a similar experience with my Vizio GV47LF, but it’s interesting to note that my screen uniformity has improved over time.

Link to review.

Also checkout our collection of VO47L customer reviews.

The Vizio VO47L Remote ControlVizio VO47L 1080p LCD HDTV

Best HDTV Deal For 2007 Black Friday is the 46″ Sharp Aquos 1080p LCD

AquosThe best deal for this year’s Black Friday may be the 46″ Sharp Aquos 1080p LCD (Model: LC-46D64U) for $1,300 (a $500 savings according to Gizmodo’s Ultimate Black Friday Deal Guide). It can be found at Circuit City. CNET.com reviewed its 52-inch brother and gave it a good review. (BlackFriday.info’s Circuit City deals.)

720p plasmas have always been a smart bargain. So, the second best deal might be the 42″ Panasonic TH-42PX75U for $900 at Best Buy. CNET hasn’t reviewed this set, but they did review its close cousin, the TH-42PX77U, which got a great review. Panasonic plasmas review very well in general.


CNET Reviews the GV52L

GV52A clear sign Vizio has become a huge player in HDTVs is that virtually every TV they release gets a CNET review. The GV52L is no exception, as it gets a thorough review from HD guru David Katzmaier. Check out the excellent review.

He gives the television an average rating and points out that plasmas in similar price range deliver better picture quality (but not 1080p). As always, these reviews should be taken in context, as David reviews $6,000 HDTVs alongside consumer sets like Vizios. A helpful quote from Katzmaier comes from his review of a 50-inch Vizio plasma:

“As you can see by reading user opinions on CNET, most people who buy an HDTV, any HDTV, are thrilled with their purchase. They cite numerous reasons, but one of the most common, at least for buyers of Vizio TVs and other bargain brands, is value”

As you always get what you pay for. But sometimes you can make your dollar go a little farther, and HDTV sets like Vizio and Westinghouse are a good way to do that.


Westinghouse’s new 47-inch 1080p HDTV, $1,500.

Westinghouse 47 inchCNET just posted their review for the new Westinghouse 47-inch HDTV LCD, the TX-47F30S. BestBuy.com has it listed for $1,500, which is $100 cheaper than Vizio’s current 47-inch LCD. The Westy has 4 HDMI inputs compared with 2 HDMI for the GV47LF. Looks like the new trend is 4 HDMI inputs.

Also of interest is CNET’s comparision of the Westy with the Vizio 42-inch LCD, the GV42LF, for its performance tests. CNET says the Vizio produces better blacks compared with the Westy. However, in the technical specifications, the Westy has a 5000:1 contrast ratio compared with the Vizio’s 1600:1. I guess even a company’s own specs won’t tell the whole tale.

CNET states the main problem with the Westy is again the black levels and screen uniformity–the same problems I experience with the Vizio GV47LF. And the strength of the Westy is color reproduction, which is also the strength of the Vizio. So it looks like the current Vizio and Westinghouse 47-inch 1080p LCDs are close matches. We’ll see if Vizio responds with a price cut or a product refresh.


What Are the Best Settings for the GV47LF?

*Updated* My views in this post have been updated. Check out my newer post, “Part II,” for professionally calibrated settings for the GV47L.

Read the rest of this entry »

My GV47LF Review: Worth Every Penny

GV47L Front Perspective

I made the plunge into the world of high definition television and purchased the GV47LF. Here is my review:

Intro

The GV47LF is a huge bargain and a great intro for first-time HDTV owners. It comes with an HDTV tuner built in and speakers (which are detachable). I am completely satisfied with the purchase. The TV works great and the overall picture quality is excellent–way beyond the standard definition experience. I am blown away by high-def television.  There were no bright or missing pixels and no mechanical problems out of the box whatsoever. This is the perfect, stress-free HDTV for any regular Joe who wants a huge 1080p HDTV but doesn’t want to go broke buying it.

In-depth Review

Now, let’s get into some details. The box the TV comes in is huge. Make sure you have a big SUV or a truck if you are purchasing it at Costco. The box was approx 4 x 3 x 1. Once unpacked and set on top of my TV stand, the TV looked much bigger than it did in the store. At first, I thought the TV was going to be too big, but now I am happy with the size, as the picture still looks great (unpixelated) at my ~8 feet viewing distance, even with 480i broadcasts.

Box

Big Box

I like how the TV looks. The black piano gloss gives the TV a finished “expensive” appearance, and the silver speakers give it weight and don’t look cheap or gaudy (although I do think the TV would look better without the speakers, which can be detached). I especially like the text in the center of the speakers that reads, “Gallevia. 1080 Progressive Liquid Crystal HDTV.” The font used for the text gives it a nice touch of stylish detail.

GV47LF Gallevia close up 2

Vizio stylin’

The glowing “Vizio” in the center of the bottom bezel was handled well. It dims to a pale white after a few seconds of brightness when you turn the television on. When the television is off, the text glows orange. I probably would rather a more basic color, like dark blue, but that’s nitpicking. They are sticking with one of their branding colors, Vizio orange, which I completely understand. The glowing symbol is not gaudy or dominating in the least. The orange glow is barely visible in normal lighting; you wouldn’t notice without looking for it. It only stands out in a dark room.


The touch controls on the right of the bottom bezel briefly glow orange when you turn the TV on, then fade to no lighting. Some might wonder why the controls don’t have the same faint lighting of the Vizio text, but it makes sense to me because most people don’t want any distractions. The fact that the remote control that comes with TV has backlighting limits the need for the controls on the TV to glow. Just don’t lose the remote!

The touch controls are a very cool. The text and symbols are beneath the surface and do not interrupt the smoothness of the bezel, giving the TV clean lines with minimal visual distractions.

HD looks awesome on the television. I went from a 24-inch Insignia CRT to this screen, and my jaw dropped to the ground when I viewed HD in my living room for the first time. I had seen HD in stores and elsewhere before, but it’s a different thing all together when you get the TV home in your own environment. 720p signals at a vewing distance of 8 feet looks crisp and perfect, there is no pixelation, as would be expected. At the time of this review, I have only viewed 720p and 1080i signals on the television.

DVDs look crisp in 480p (with component cables) and do not appear pixelated at a viewing distance of 8 feet. The big weakness of the TV are black levels, but I want to point out that even though I will talk a lot about the black levels, I find them not to detract much form the overall viewing experience. However, it is noticeable, even to my amateur eye. Any time the screen fades to black or there is a scene that is almost entirely dark, the GV47LF shows black as ghostly black-grey, not black. There is also clouding, which is an unevenness to the blackness on the screen, displaying clouds or splotches of lighter shades. This was noticeable several times on Star Wars: Episode III: Revenge of the Sith. The weak black levels are most noticeable if you like to watch movies in completely dark rooms. It’s recommended you keep at least a low level of ambient light (turn on a single lamp with a dimmed setting), especially during movies with dark lighting or lots of space scenes. Check out my post of the best settings for the GV47LF or view CNET’s recommended dark room picture settings for help in improving the picture in to dim to dark lighting.

GV47LF Remote

It’s not remotely bad


Before I bought the television, I heard a lot of complaints about the remote. I think it’s fine. There is a lot of space between the buttons, so that basically makes up for the small size of the channel and volume buttons (see picture above). I find the commonly used buttons (channels and volume) easy to find without looking. It is also a “universal” control with programming for VCR, cable, and DVD players. Of course, if you have the cash, I’m sure there are plenty of better controllers for your money.

GV47LF Small Text

Time to see the eye doctor?

Another complaint is the small text of the Vizio’s menu. At eight feet, I have problems reading the text and have to approach the television to be able to read the settings. A small annoyance that seems like it should be easily fixed. Come on Vizio, just increase those font sizes!

There is an “info” button which allows you to see what signal is going into the television (1080i, 720p, etc), but the text is likewise hard to read.

Input

Vizio adds another touch of class by including a microfiber cloth to keep all the accidental smudges clean from your television. Whatever you do, don’t use Windex (you can damage your screen).

Cloth1Cloth2

 

Keep your Vizio dust free

The detachable speakers deliver adequate sound. They are loud enough for everyday living rooms, even those complete with loud ambient noise (kids playing in the next room). For those who have their own sound system, the speakers are detachable via a screwdriver.

Conclusion:

There is very little to complain about with this television. High definition content is delivered beautifully with bright colors and no motion blurring. 480p DVD signals are also displayed crisp and clear. Clouding and black levels are the biggest con of the television, but are acceptable with a little tweaking. The screen is huge for those who sit 7-10 feet away from their TV. Anything above 50 inches would seem redundant and perhaps detrimental to the HD viewing experience. And you can’t beat the current $1,599 price at Costco with a 90 day return policy. This is the perfect television for 1080p hunters who are looking for a bargain.

More pictures of my TV below.

GV47LF Front

GV47LF Down Low

GV47L Side View GV47LF


Samsung LN-T3253H: The Less Obnoxious Choice? (32 inch, ~$1000)

Samsung LN-T3253H

Big HDTVs can be obnoxious. I remember walking into an apartment and seeing a 60-inch Sony XBR with a couch set less than five feet in front of it. The owners obviously didn’t buy the TV for the viewing experience. So, I was thinking, maybe I don’t want an obnoxious-sized TV in my apartment. A visitor’s first impression of my apartment shouldn’t be my TV. This 32-inch Samsung seems to fit my personality a little better. It has one of the top HDTV CNET reviews. However, it seems pretty expensive for only 32 inches of screen. Let’s see, you get 47 inches for $1700 or 32 inches for $1000. Hmmmm.

There’s also another new Samsung LCD (the LN-T4665F) that was just reviewed on CNET that has received the best LCD review yet, so I’m excited to see what this round of LCDs brings. The longer you wait, the better the television you’re going to get.

The Research: the Pros and Cons of the Vizio GV47LF (47 inch, ~$1700)

GV47LF

I went into my Costco yesterday (my first time in a Costco) in Chicago to check it out in person. They had the GV47LF set next to a $2200 Sharp Aqous, and I could really see a difference in the black levels. Another thing I noticed was pixelation during very fast motion, but I’m pretty sure it was just the HD source, not the television, since it was occuring on the Sharp too. I’m still thinking this purchase through, and to help me, I’m writing out my research and my thoughts. Here are the cons of the GF47LF (pros to come shortly). I culled these from various sources on the Internet and gathered them here for your information (note: sources are most notably the CNET review and postings form the GV47LF thread on AVS forum):

  1. As CNET pointed out in their review, the GV47LF’s black levels show lighter than most plasmas and some LCDs. In their tests, the letterbox bars appeared grayer than with the other HDTVs. This is not a problem limited to the GV47LF–it’s common in most LCDs. The black levels of LCD screens are slowly improving, but they still fall short of plasmas. However, there comes a point when black is as black as it’s going to get. Owners of LCDs say these black levels are only noticeable when comparing one HDTV to another. But once you get the screen home, you don’t notice the lightness of the blacks. For instance, you wouldn’t view a shot of space and think, “Wow, space is actually gray!”
  2. Some owners are experiencing audio synching problems, with the audio lagging behind the video. On AVSforum.com, they are debating whether it’s the TV or the HDTV source (cable TV + over-the-air broadcast).
  3. No dot-by-dot aspect ratio mode with 1080i sources.
  4. Nondefeatable overscan causes horizontal stretching. This means a circle will look more like an oval. An AVSforum.com poster claimed the GV47LF stretches the picture 3%-5% of all HDTV sources except for 1080p.
  5. The standard definition viewing experience will be a step down from normal (CRT) viewing.
  6. The remote is almost useless. You’ll have to purchase a new one.
  7. The menus on the television have an almost unreadable yellow text on gray background.
  8. Some owners have reported an annoying speaker buzz.

Now the Pros. Most are fairly obvious:

  1. The price, which is currently $1,599 (with Costco membership). What other flat screen is comparable? Look for yourself. There are 720p plasmas this size or bigger that are close in price, but do you want a 50-inch plasma with 720p?
  2. 1080p, which means it’s future proof. I’m not sold that cable  TV will get to 1080p within a couple years, but I do believe that other kinds of content will, and the ratio of cable TV you watch vs, say, computer (internet) or gaming content will slowly tip toward the latter.
  3. 47 inches. I live in 1 and a half bedroom apartment, and this size TV is perfect. Just on the verge of being too big, but still perfect.
  4. 2-year warranty from Costco. If you buy today and a pixel goes dead in May 2009, you’re covered.
  5. 90-day return policy. If you hate the TV, the only pain you’ll be feeling is having to haul it back to Costco.
  6. Removable speakers. I have need of the speakers, but one day I won’t. It’s very nice to have the option to remove them.